You have $22,000 across a few credit cards at a high rate. Two common ways to replace them are a debt consolidation loan and a home equity line of credit (HELOC) chunk. Both move the balance to a lower rate. They behave very differently afterward.

The consolidation loan is an installment loan, which means a fixed amount, a fixed rate, and a fixed term. Suppose it's $22,000 at 11 percent for 60 months. The payment is about $478 a month, and you'd pay about $6,700 in interest over the five years. Many of these loans also charge an origination fee, often a few percent of the loan. At 3 percent on $22,000 that's $660, taken from the loan up front.

The HELOC chunk uses a revolving line, which means you can borrow, pay back, and borrow again up to a limit. Say the rate is 8.5 percent and variable. You pay off the cards with a single draw. Then you keep paying the balance down as fast as your surplus lets you. If you can send $1,000 a month, the balance is gone in about 25 months, and the interest comes to about $2,000. That doesn't count any savings from parking your paycheck on the line of credit, which lowers the average daily balance even more.

Notice what each one does. The consolidation loan locks you into $478 a month for 60 months no matter what. That's a protection if you'd spend any extra cash you had, and an anchor if you wanted to pay it off faster, since extra payments usually save interest only if the loan allows them without a penalty. When the loan is paid, the money you paid in is gone from your reach.

The HELOC works differently. The dollars you pay down stay available on the line of credit, so a slow month can be covered without a new card. The risks sit on that side too. The rate moves with the market, the lender can cut the limit, and a flexible payment only helps people who set their own schedule and keep to it. If you don't, the balance lingers and the lower rate stops mattering.

A few more things. A HELOC needs equity in a home you own, and a consolidation loan doesn't. Both can show up on your credit report. And neither fixes the habit that created the card balances, so make sure the cards aren't running up again.

Write down the three numbers for each option: the rate, the up-front fees, and the monthly payment you'd need to finish in 24 months. Three numbers per option settle it: the rate, the up-front fees, and the monthly payment needed to finish in 24 months.